Are Allotment Growers Irrational?

John Harrison with potatoes on allotment

Am I crazy to grow my own?

Having just finished our competition where people told us why they ‘grow your own’ I was browsing and I read on the low impact org web site that: “Having an allotment and growing veg is irrational. It’s much easier to work for a wage, and then buy your fruit and veg from a supermarket – that’s by far the cheapest option, involving the least work.”

I must admit to being biased on the subject of growing your own but that had me shouting at the screen!

OK, it makes sense superficially for an economist and ignores all the social and health benefits that allotments and growing your own offer to us. But let’s look at it from the point of view of the majority of the population.

To get a wage you need a job!

A wage involves having a job. To many people that’s just not possible and even if it were the sort of job they can get offers nothing beyond monetary compensation for their time. As you get older you appreciate time is one resource that is limited and in short supply.

There’s no fulfilment in most jobs and those at the base of the pecking order are usually the worst. Operated under zero hour contracts with the constant threat of removal of work. Called in to suit others with precious little freedom to decide when you want or are free to work.

Is growing work or pleasure?

The ‘work’ of growing is more of a pleasure than a chore. I’ve had some pretty rotten jobs over the years – some well paid some not. I needed the money because you can’t pay the rent or the mortgage any other way. Shovelling a pile of horse muck may not be glamorous but it beats a lot of those jobs I had.

Here’s the question

So, would you rather spend 200 hours a year of your life doing something that challenges the mind, refreshes the spirit and exercises the body or waste 100 hours doing some repetitive, boring tasks for a faceless company so that you can go and buy your vegetables from a giant multi-national corporation who will pass on a small portion of the price to the farmer who actually grew the product.

With British grown vegetables that farmer manages to supply the supermarkets only by using cheap labour usually from eastern Europe. Often this labour force is treated in a way that is tantamount to slavery, run by gangmasters some of whom are little more than gangsters.

The vegetables themselves are hardly comparable. Pumped up by high chemical inputs, sprayed with a cocktail of pesticides and shopped for, at best, hundreds of miles from where they were grown versus ultra-fresh, home-grown grown but yards away.

I’d love to see your comments.

Posted in Allotment Garden Diary
3 comments on “Are Allotment Growers Irrational?
  1. Pete Hare says:

    I have just got an allotment last august. I spent about an hour a day Until I had turned it all over and de-weeded it. My two friend said all that digging but I saw as some much needed exercise. I have yet to harvest anything But I am looking forward to next year.

  2. Karen Griffiths says:

    Irrational??!! No way, passionate about health and the environment, then definitely yes! There are few things more satisfying than taking tiny seeds and growing wonderful and delicious food which the whole family benefit from. I am well and truly hooked.

  3. Paul says:

    Allotment vs. gym? And then there are the organic vegs, if the plot isn’t contaminated before you got it. I just got one and I’m busy cleaning the rubbish. Fortunately the tip is in walking distance. But that’s exercise too.

Leave a Comment Here on Are Allotment Growers Irrational?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


July 2024

What to do now on your plot!

Monthly Free Newsletter

Allotment Photo History

Our Books – A Growing Offer!

Our bestselling books for growing success!
More Information


Allotment & Garden Online Planning

Free Trial - Allotment Planner
Personal Planting Updates & Tips
by email twice a month
Allotment Garden Planning Software